Money Pit - next chapter
-
-
And this, gentle readers, is why we passed up the glorious old farmhouses with barns, and ponds, and land 5 years ago. The houses we’d always dreamed of owning when we retired.
20 years of maintaining a 100 YO apartment building took the romance out of that dream and we ended up with a 3 YO tract house.
-
We’ve been living in an 1887 Victorian for the past 50 years.
If we move again, it will be into something different.
BUT it still is so satisfying to look up and admire the tall ceilings, woodwork and generous rooms.
-
And this, gentle readers, is why we passed up the glorious old farmhouses with barns, and ponds, and land 5 years ago. The houses we’d always dreamed of owning when we retired.
20 years of maintaining a 100 YO apartment building took the romance out of that dream and we ended up with a 3 YO tract house.
And this, gentle readers, is why we passed up the glorious old farmhouses with barns, and ponds, and land 5 years ago. The houses we’d always dreamed of owning when we retired.
20 years of maintaining a 100 YO apartment building took the romance out of that dream and we ended up with a 3 YO tract house.
Yeah, that romance wears off with age. I used to love remodeling my house. Even painting. No mas.
-
I've always regarded home renovation as a personal war where one might win a battle - but the war is never won - metaphors of Afghanistan or Vietnam come to mind. It's amusing because one has the hope that just around the corner is victory - but around the corner is...another corner.
-
-
Right now, I'm just trying to find someone willing to go up on our 2 story roof and use a strong stick to see if we can at least temporarily break through the rust barrier - while we work on the final game plan. Thanksgiving may get cancelled if we fail.
-
-
Roofing company?
Probably 25 years ago we had something like 3 feet of snow over the course of a few weeks. People were starting to have structural issues because of the weight of the snow on the roof. Friends found a roofer willing to go up on the roof and shovel off some of the snow. We got his number and called him and he did the job.
-
Right now, I'm just trying to find someone willing to go up on our 2 story roof and use a strong stick to see if we can at least temporarily break through the rust barrier - while we work on the final game plan. Thanksgiving may get cancelled if we fail.
That rust-in-the-vent stack diagnosis sounds mighty suspect. That is not how they fail - they rust through. Not impossible but not likely.
I’d get another opinion.
-
That rust-in-the-vent stack diagnosis sounds mighty suspect. That is not how they fail - they rust through. Not impossible but not likely.
I’d get another opinion.
That rust-in-the-vent stack diagnosis sounds mighty suspect. That is not how they fail - they rust through. Not impossible but not likely.
I’d get another opinion.
Thanks, Steve. I have a guy coming this morning. I'll have him take pictures so I get a better idea of what is going on. That's what happened to one of my neighbors.
IF it is a blockage, i hope he might clear a bit of the blockage so that my guests on Thursday can use the bathroom without affixiation.
After that, the question I have is whether we can just replace the stack and hook into the existing piping in the upstairs bath - OR do we just demolish the bathroom again - which would require us to move out for a month>
-
I've always regarded home renovation as a personal war where one might win a battle - but the war is never won - metaphors of Afghanistan or Vietnam come to mind. It's amusing because one has the hope that just around the corner is victory - but around the corner is...another corner.
I've always regarded home renovation as a personal war where one might win a battle - but the war is never won - metaphors of Afghanistan or Vietnam come to mind. It's amusing because one has the hope that just around the corner is victory - but around the corner is...another corner.
Uh huh. I was president of one of our HOA recreation associations, responsible for a large clubhouse, ponds, docks, pool, tennis courts, etc. At one meeting someone said something about, "When the clubhouse is all done, we can...". I just laughed and laughed. There's no such thing as done. It's the Forever War.
-
Been thinking about this all morning.
Is your attic access near the bathroom where the vent stack is? If you stick your head up there can you see the vent stack as it runs through the attic? Does it run straight up through the roof or does it angle toward the center of the roof and then continue up? A lot of them do. If that’s the case the stick is hitting a pipe fitting, not a blockage. Did your plumber look in the attic?
If he did, and you know the length of the stick, you know how far down the blockage is and can go right to it, possibly in the attic.
You do have a blockage, as evidenced by the sink gurgling when the toilet is flushed. Odd that it only showed up when the new toilet was installed - can’t figure that one out. New toilet flushes faster than the old one?
Old houses are unpredictable but plumbing codes haven’t changed much since the turn of the last century. The fact the sink gurgles indicates that you have a “re-vent” setup where the sink vent ties in to the main vent somewhere higher than the sink, probably in line with the toilet. The blockage would have to be above that height or possibly in that connection. That would suggest that you’d have to cut the wall from about 5’ off of the floor to the bathroom ceiling to find it. Not a huge cut.
Chicago has a unique set of codes resulting from the great fire. Around here modern waste plumbing is plastic but you may be stuck with cast iron. Even if it’s cast iron the repair doesn’t sound like it has to be all that destructive.
If the repair does require breaking in to the main drain stack it might pay to have a camera run down it to see if complete replacement is warranted. Won’t be cheap but there probably isn’t much wrong with it and a camera run will be cheaper than replacing the stack on a guess. There may be a reason that’s not feasible but it’s something to consider.
Disclaimer: I am not a plumber, I don’t know your house, and I don’t know Chicago codes. I do know how venting works and have been in charge of several projects to correct it. YMMV.
I hope you’ll post pictures of what the project looks like and what the blockage is.
Good luck!
-
-
Steve, thanks - very good thoughts - and appreciate your sharing. OOPS - and just saw your update - yes, that picture pretty much describes our system.
From FB, I've gotten a plumber who is willing to come out and spend a bit of time to sort out the issue. In the meantime, I'll climb into the attic and see if the stack goes straight - or does a bend. I hadn't thought of that possibility. My neighbor whose house is identical - said he had his stack replaced about 5 years ago and after all was said and done, he spent about $30K - as he remodeled his bath. I want to avoid that - as I'd hate to tear up everything and have to replaced tile on walls, floor, etc. - but if that's absolutely necessary, we'll do it.
I had a roofer willing to come out and try and do the break through, but once I got a note from a bona fide plumber, I'd rather have that kind of expertise as I can imagine a non-plumber might cause more damage than help if he didn't know what he's doing.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
