Skip to content

Off Key - General Discussion

3.7k Topics 25.5k Posts

A place to talk about whatever you want

  • Pinned threads

    Pinned
    4
    4 Posts
    1k Views
    S
    Great!
  • 13 Posts
    51 Views
    RontunerR
    Skimming through, the main difference measured seems to be the acceleration of the hammer just before escapement - that moment when the key disengages from the hammer and it is free to continue on to the string without any connection to the finger. We are talking about the last little bit of motion - around 1/16", though often wider on many pianos. So not just speed, but how much that speed is changing right before it releases to the string. Interesting stuff! (I think this showed up on one of the tech forums when first published)
  • Trump had a physical last week

    3
    1
    3 Posts
    20 Views
    B
    ROFLMAO!
  • OperaTenor

    12
    1
    12 Posts
    71 Views
    DougGD
    I think Jim was the first person I met in person from any of these forms. we got together when I was down in San Diego on business, it must’ve been more than 20 years ago. He was also at a piano party that Kenny threw about that same time. very sad news.
  • Payam Method for piano lessons

    38
    38 Posts
    230 Views
    B
    @wtg said: Anyway, I wonder if people who are immersed in music, have a brain wired for it, and who devote a lot of time and energy to it, see this as the equivalent of cheap wine in the world of piano lessons, and somehow not up to their standards. We need to remember that for some people, cheap wine is totally OK and even enjoyable! Maybe Payam will get folks into playing, enjoying, and spreading piano music and spreading piano music widely. I think that's a good thing. I think some (perhaps a lot) of established teachers are up in arms over Payam because it is promoting itself by propagating blatant falsehoods about traditional and other methods. To suddenly appear and tell everyone they've been doing it wrong with nothing more than flimsy marketing isn't going to settle with people who, as you said, have invested themselves heavily (money and time) in the study of music and teaching it. A good thing because it may get more people interested in piano? There is a limit. They are cheating their teachers by taking 75% of the lesson income. One has to question the quality of the teachers they will obtain. The way I see Payam right now, it's like those "Learn piano in 2 weeks" frauds that comes along every now and then. But if it works for someone, if only to get them interested, that could be seen as a benefit. And as it was pointed out in the video I posted, Payam's method is not all that dissimilar to a lot of standard methods, despite their claims. But I am worried that they will be taking advantage of ignorance. And it does sound like their main interest is financial, not musical.
  • Kairos: The ancient Greek art of knowing when to act

    4
    4 Posts
    27 Views
    D
    @axtremus No worries. It's relatively alive for something that's dead.
  • What do chefs cook at home?

    6
    6 Posts
    41 Views
    AxtremusA
    Not that hard to find out. Just ask the children of professional chefs. The answers are ultimately of little consequence to the general public.
  • AI has confirmation bias

    5
    5 Posts
    49 Views
    AxtremusA
    Are you accusing the Republicans of being artificial or intelligent?
  • Today is International Flight Attendants Day

    3
    3 Posts
    27 Views
    ShiroKuroS
    @jon-nyc said: She has the same haircut 67 years later and it looks great in both pictures. That is a life skill I would like to emulate!
  • Remarkable use of our tax dollars

    politics
    22
    22 Posts
    238 Views
    B
    @wtg From the brief filed by 35 former federal judges: “The parties have used this lawsuit—which was never an adversarial proceeding over which the Court even had jurisdiction—as a means to allow a “commission” controlled by the President to dole out $1.776 billion in taxpayer dollars without constitutional or congressional authority to do so, and to confer unlawful private benefits to the President and his family by purportedly prohibiting the United States from prosecuting any and all claims against them. And the parties have plainly tried to shield this conduct from necessary judicial scrutiny by short-circuiting this Court’s inquiry into whether the lawsuit is in fact an actual case or controversy by [seeking to dismiss the case] before they announced the “settlement”—clearly in hopes of preventing the Court from ever completing that inquiry, which, if it comes out against the parties, will undo their collusive “settlement.” …. Accordingly, because “[t]he parties’ ‘collusive’ activity perpetrated a fraud on the judicial machinery itself, by fostering an appearance that the litigation involved adverse parties, when, in fact, it did not,” the Court should void its prior dismissal and reopen the case to assess in due course whether a fraud occurred.”
  • Bloomscrolling--what's in bloom where you are?

    319
    319 Posts
    36k Views
    AdagioMA
    My peony is blooming. It was just about to pop last Saturday when I left for Phoenix. When I got home on Thursday, they were already looking a little ragged. [image: 1780197065967-img_2747.jpeg] But individually they are spectacular. [image: 1780197097430-img_2745.jpeg] [image: 1780197107940-img_2746.jpeg] I’ve cut a few that were lying low (they’re so heavy when they bloom, they want to lie down), and put them in a vase on the front porch table.
  • Kennedy Center

    31
    31 Posts
    1k Views
    wtgW
    Deeper dive into the points raised by the retired judges: https://www.npr.org/2026/05/30/nx-s1-5839989/judge-review-trump-anti-weaponization-fund And here's their amicus brief: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/28176766-motion-from-35-former-federal-judges/
  • Spain's approach to immigration

    5
    5 Posts
    56 Views
    wtgW
    That makes sense.
  • Heat waves in the UK and India

    5
    5 Posts
    53 Views
    wtgW
    Amazing map showing where the heat waves are. https://www.space.com/astronomy/earth/its-so-hot-across-europe-you-can-see-the-heat-wave-from-space-space-photo-of-the-day-for-may-29-2026
  • Typhoid is making a comeback

    1
    1 Posts
    19 Views
    No one has replied
  • The escalation trap and how to get out of it

    2
    2 Posts
    32 Views
    wtgW
    How to escape the trap by Elli Lieberman https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/escalation-trap-pape-and-lieberman-on-iran-war/
  • CBS Scholarship winner acceptance speech

    6
    6 Posts
    63 Views
    D
    I only wish that human beings could bring themselves to admit to themselves and others that they have been and are watching a live streamed genocide in Gaza and other places in Palestine. We were taught to, "never forget." We were taught to believe in international law. We taught ourself that, "holocaust" is a word that no group of human beings owns. The new owner of CBS is a Zionist billionaire that has given more money to the IDF than anyone in history. CBS does not, as no media conglomerate does, operate under the FCC framework that we remember because the framework has been demolished. CBS is now the definition of propaganda. No true journalist can work for it as a reporter. The people who work at CBS now are stenographers. This young person is promising because he hasn't agreed to betray journalism by being a stenographer. I agree completely that everyone must make their way in the world. I understand on the other hand that this is entirely possible to do without supporting a holocaust.
  • Mark Cuban Cost Plus Drugs

    5
    5 Posts
    55 Views
    J
    I tried to use it once for otc stuff they sell (can’t even remember what it was) and their website simply wouldn’t let me proceed without a prescription.
  • More lawfare

    politics
    12
    12 Posts
    80 Views
    J
    @Mik said: Pandora's box was opened from 2015 on. What happened in 2015?
  • Tuner - finally, a movie about a piano tuner

    6
    6 Posts
    52 Views
    ShiroKuroS
    @wtg said: A book about a piano tuner. Thanks, I added it to my list. This reminds me of something I listened to as an audiobook. The title is unfortunately a bit generic, but I really enjoyed it. Love Is Blind, by William Boyd The description makes it just sound like a cheesy romance, but as I recall, there's a lot about piano tuning and music in there that elevated it beyond that. When he is hired as the personal piano tuner for a brilliant pianist, Brodie Moncur suddenly finds himself swept up into a life of luxury that he could never have imagined. But while accompanying his new employer on tours from Paris to St. Petersburg, Brodie falls madly in love with the Russian soprano Lika Blum: beautiful, worldly, seductive—and forbidden. Though seemingly doomed from the start, Brodie’s passion for Lika only grows as their lives become increasingly more intertwined, more secretive, and, finally, more dangerous. A tale of dizzying passion and brutal revenge; of artistic endeavor and the illusions it can create; of the possibilities that life offers and the cruel speed with which they can be snatched away, Love Is Blind is a dazzling work of historical fiction that unfolds across fin de siècle Europe.