https://www.countrylife.co.uk/architecture/architects-and-ancestry-the-country-house-thats-spent-900-years-in-the-same-family
Here we arrive at a topic I haven't covered, and I'm surprised I haven't had an occasion to cover until now.
Look at this magnificent house.
It could be the seat of an earl with a peerage title.
And yet, no.
This brings me to my topic.
The owners of this house do not hold a peerage title. They hold a feudal title.
I'm familiar with feudal titles because I was online friends with a gentleman who held one, during the 7 years I posted at the original watch forums.
I'll get to him in just a minute.
I think I understood the part about matrilineal descendants using a patriarchal surname in a "because I can" sort of way.
Google AI search for the title, not the house-
"The Lordship of the Seigniory of Holderness is a historic feudal and manorial title covering the region of Holderness in the East Riding of Yorkshire, England.
Key History
• Origins: Following the Norman Conquest, the seigniory was established as a major territorial honor, held historically by figures such as Odo Count of Champagne, the Counts of Albemarle, and Isabella de Fortibus during the reign of Henry III.
• Acquisition by the Constables: In the 1550s, Sir John Constable purchased the Lordship of the Seigniory of Holderness.
• Burton Constable Hall: The owners of the seigniory have been seated at Burton Constable Hall, an Elizabethan and Georgian country house whose core estate has remained in the family for nine centuries without ever being sold.
• Historical Documentation: The definitive historical study of the region is George Poulson's two-volume work, The History and Antiquities of the Seigniory of Holderness (1840–1841), compiled from ancient charters and the manuscripts of the Rev. William Dade."
As for my friend, he was an interesting character. He was born in the German speaking part of Switzerland, made a fortune (or at least I think he did, knowing him as I did m, I doubt he inherited it, had expatriated to Thailand by the time I knew him, and had bought himself a feudal earldom in Scotland.
This is where you go to buy an official feudal title in Scotland (edit, I think you still can but I'm not going to research it):
index https://share.google/gaWhAhYpGY3Z24jPS
My friend was always getting in trouble with them.
They were upset with him because he was entitled to style himself:
[Legal name here], Earl of Arran, but he styled himself "Lord Arran" and refused to stop.
Looking at this now, I see that Scotland detached feudal titles from land. Interesting.
I doubt this phased my friend, either. He did own the island and the castle. (I doubt he ever saw them.)
My friend, the trouble maker. Lol.-
"The feudal title or territorial earldom of Arran refers to a rare barony-level land and title concept in Scotland, distinct from the actual peerage title.
Key Distinctions
• Peerage vs. Feudal Title: The true peerage title of Earl of Arran in the Peerage of Scotland is a historic noble title currently held as a subsidiary title by the Duke of Hamilton.
• The Feudal Claim: A feudal or territorial concept of the earldom became famous when Swiss millionaire Willi Ernst Sturzenegger purchased land on the Isle of Arran—including Lochranza Castle—in the 1990s and attempted to gain official recognition as the "Feudal Earl of Arran".
• Legal Status: The Court of the Lord Lyon and Scottish courts rejected attempts to elevate a territorial or feudal land holding into an actual earldom dignity, especially following the Abolition of Feudal Tenure etc. (Scotland) Act 2000, which ended the legal framework of feudal baronies and titles in Scotland"
He kept wanting the Court to grant him privileges they couldn't, and he kept breaking their rules at the same time.
I have a couple thoughts.
He was, along with myself, one of the 7 original members of the forum. The point was that to delete a post according to community standards, there was a rule that 4 members had to publicly vote down the post (it happener once and I was the 4th vote, but nevermind).
But unlike the moderator and her best friend (and the 3 of us were close), he and I weren't close.
My main thought about it is that this gentleman was vain.
He did this as a kind of "calling card" to present himself to people as someone he was not.
Moreover, I think it you're going to sign up for something, especially something like this, then play by the rules.
Trying to drive legitimacy from an institution when you don't respect the institution's own legitimacy is plain irrational.
Finally, it certainly wasn't my business to tell him how to spend his money, but I personally would never, no matter how much money I had, buy a castle in Scotland and never even visit it.
Vain definitely, and silly in a way, but he was, and I'll give him this much- he certainly shared, it to a lesser degree, my feelings about our moderator, a Detroit stalwart and brilliant writer (beyond brilliant), whose father owned a record shop and who was the first person to record Aretha Franklin.
I'll link to that album in my music thread.
I can't say that I haven't lived an interesting life so far. Lol.