Peanut Butter
-
Love peanut butter and the Med diet guy says it will help me live longer. But every year they add more and more sugar until now it tastes like peanut butter cookies.
Tried the hippie organic stuff. It’s unsweetened but it’s oily and a hot mess to re incorporate. Put it in the fridge to stabilize it and it sets up like concrete. Reddit informs me that you can’t make PB that doesn’t separate without sugar, and when I pointed out that in the 60’s it didn’t have sugar they accused me of senility. I gave up, haven’t bought it in years. Sharon buys Jif for the grandson but I don’t eat it. I can feel it rotting the teeth right out of my head.
But today I found this. Jif unsweetened peanut butter. Jif - the sweetest of an oversweet lot - appears to have found the light. Doesn’t separate. Tastes like baseball game peanuts including the slightly funky taste that reminds me of skins left on and makes me wonder if they haven’t gone slightly rancid.
Delicious! I went back and bought four jars. It won’t be out for long and will end up at Big Lots in a month or two. But right now I’m really happy.
-
Love peanut butter and the Med diet guy says it will help me live longer. But every year they add more and more sugar until now it tastes like peanut butter cookies.
Tried the hippie organic stuff. It’s unsweetened but it’s oily and a hot mess to re incorporate. Put it in the fridge to stabilize it and it sets up like concrete. Reddit informs me that you can’t make PB that doesn’t separate without sugar, and when I pointed out that in the 60’s it didn’t have sugar they accused me of senility. I gave up, haven’t bought it in years. Sharon buys Jif for the grandson but I don’t eat it. I can feel it rotting the teeth right out of my head.
But today I found this. Jif unsweetened peanut butter. Jif - the sweetest of an oversweet lot - appears to have found the light. Doesn’t separate. Tastes like baseball game peanuts including the slightly funky taste that reminds me of skins left on and makes me wonder if they haven’t gone slightly rancid.
Delicious! I went back and bought four jars. It won’t be out for long and will end up at Big Lots in a month or two. But right now I’m really happy.
@Steve-Miller nice!
I have gone through the peanut butter search thing myself, and trying to find peanut butter that doesn’t have a pound of sugar in it but is still edible is a nightmare!
I’ll have to try this!
-
Has a little Palm oil in it. Not sure why, but cynical me thinks that Palm oil is cheaper than peanut oil and JIF can sell the excess peanut oil as something good to fry a turkey in for more money. Palm oil has environmental issues but I’ll lower my standards for peanut butter that tastes like this.
-
Glad you found a solution, Steve.
I am fond of almond butter, which usually comes unsweetened, but it has the same separating issue as peanut butter. I try to buy new stock that hasn’t separated much. Using it and stirring it every couple of days helps.
There are hand-cranked gizmos that screw onto your jar and supposedly make the mixing easier. Also a school of thought that says you should just store the jars upside down.
Another solution: buy small jars that are easier to work with.
SK, my cookbooks tell me that for things like an Asian peanut sauce, you get best flavor from an Asian brand of peanut butter. I’ve tried one and they are different. Absolutely not sweet, a bit bitter, and dark in color (skins left on?)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
