SK's latest piano recording and the PT recital
-
-
-
Thanks @bernard and @jon-nyc !
Jon, Yes still working on the Debussy — it’s crazy how hard it feels. I’m up to measure 54 out of 72, I want to get through the whole piece before my lessons end for the semester and then I can start actually working on playing it, and working on bringing to the tempo, over winter break.
-
-
-
-
Thanks @daniel!
I had my piano lesson yesterday, we worked mostly on Claire de Lune and another piece, but at the end of the lesson, I played this for her and we talked about tempo and dynamics and just general musicality stuff. Usually the pieces we work on in lessons are things I can’t play yet, and usually when I record something, often I’m done with it and I don’t bring it into the lesson after that. But it’s really nice to work on something that I can actually play, and then talk about more advanced musicality things.
Also she clapped after I finished playing it (something she never does) so that was sweet.

-
Sounds like it was a good lesson.
Speaking of clapping... there is no clapping in our group performance class. It was a little unnerving at first. In every other group class I've ever taken, everyone always clapped when someone finished playing. In this class: silence. Usually the performer or teacher will break the silence, the former by offering some opinion on what just happened, the latter by asking everyone for input.
I have come to really like it this way. Clapping breaks the focus of what we're in class for, and in a way it can be dishonest, in a benign way. It is really nice not to have this frivolous custom constantly intruding on our work!
Everything seems clearer without it; no mixed messages. -
@shirokuro my teacher is like that with pieces I had learned prior to starting lessons with him as well as pieces we have "finished" but will need polishing for some time. It is very inspiring. I used to be suspicious of the clapping. lol. Thinking it was him "just being nice". But I know it to be sincere because when I played the Intro to the Genesis song, "Firth of Fifth" from their 1973 album, "Selling England by the Pound" he actually gave me what was a real, involuntary standing ovation with some very nice accolades. Wow! was one of them. lol!
The past Saturday we started lessons again. I played the first Mendelsohn piece I recently learned on my own and the Chopin Nocturne Op 72 No 1 which was the last piece we worked on before summer break. We never "finished" the Nocturne. I "finished" learning it over the summer as well. He clapped and said some very complimentary things after each piece. Then we started looking at the areas that "need some work" lol.
I love taking lessons. The knowledge I gained in just 60 minutes last weekend already have me playing the "areas in question" much better.
-
Sounds like it was a good lesson.
Speaking of clapping... there is no clapping in our group performance class. It was a little unnerving at first. In every other group class I've ever taken, everyone always clapped when someone finished playing. In this class: silence. Usually the performer or teacher will break the silence, the former by offering some opinion on what just happened, the latter by asking everyone for input.
I have come to really like it this way. Clapping breaks the focus of what we're in class for, and in a way it can be dishonest, in a benign way. It is really nice not to have this frivolous custom constantly intruding on our work!
Everything seems clearer without it; no mixed messages.Clapping breaks the focus of what we're in class for
I can see how this makes sense. You're there to work on the music, it's a lesson or an exercise rather than a performance. And I think context matters -- in the context of your class, the expectation is no clapping, that's fine. I don't have a problem with that.
But I have to say, I don't see how clapping should be interpreted as mixed message or dishonest. You've worked hard to get the piece to where it is. Clapping doesn't have to mean "you're done, this is perfect." It can just mean "well done. Good job getting to this point." And that's a message I'm happy to hear, or share with someone else.
In a performance situation, I like clapping, both as a listener, and clapping for what I've just heard, and as a performer, receiving clapping for the performance I just finished.
And in the context of my lesson, where I played the piece for my teacher in a much more finished presentation than she's heard it before, and maybe especially because the clapping was so unexpected, I was quite pleased to receive her applause.
Life is short. My take is that showing and receiving appreciation is great and we should do it more!

-
@shirokuro my teacher is like that with pieces I had learned prior to starting lessons with him as well as pieces we have "finished" but will need polishing for some time. It is very inspiring. I used to be suspicious of the clapping. lol. Thinking it was him "just being nice". But I know it to be sincere because when I played the Intro to the Genesis song, "Firth of Fifth" from their 1973 album, "Selling England by the Pound" he actually gave me what was a real, involuntary standing ovation with some very nice accolades. Wow! was one of them. lol!
The past Saturday we started lessons again. I played the first Mendelsohn piece I recently learned on my own and the Chopin Nocturne Op 72 No 1 which was the last piece we worked on before summer break. We never "finished" the Nocturne. I "finished" learning it over the summer as well. He clapped and said some very complimentary things after each piece. Then we started looking at the areas that "need some work" lol.
I love taking lessons. The knowledge I gained in just 60 minutes last weekend already have me playing the "areas in question" much better.
My take is much more in line with Mark's comments.
And also this:
I love taking lessons. The knowledge I gained in just 60 minutes last weekend already have me playing the "areas in question" much better.
I love taking lessons too! Someone at Piano|Tell asked me why I still take lessons after I've been playing for so long. The question strikes me as being based on a fundamental misunderstanding about 1) the point of lessons, and 2) the process of piano playing.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
