Help me figure out how to play/practice this
-
So, the piece I’ve picked for my final jury (which is in exactly three weeks now!) is coming along well, except for two spots (isn’t that always the way).
One of them is this short passage of 5- and 4-finger chords, below. Besides prepping this for the jury, I do also want to record it to share.
Merry Christmas Mr. Lawrence, by Ryuichi Sakamoto

When I play this in my lesson, it’s mostly ok-ish, but at home, my keyboard (Yamaha C2 acoustic grand) feels heavy (maybe it is) and my RH sort of quickly fatigues, for lack of a better word. I do suspect that my keyboard is heavy, and I was actually going to ask my tuner about it (for example, have I just never noticed it, or could it be heavier now for some reason). Since it feels easier to play on the lesson piano, I do suspect that the heaviness of my keyboard is a factor. But this is the piano I have and I need to be able to play this piece on this piano.
And I also think that the fatigue and achy tiredness my hand feels after practicing this part suggests I have tension I don’t need. But probably because the lesson piano (which is a beat up old Steinway, as is common at the music school) has a much lighter keyboard, I think my teacher maybe isn’t seeing the problems that I’m feeling when I work on it home. We’ve talked about having flatter fingers, we’ve talked about the distance of the hand from the fallboard etc. so I’ve experimented with tweaking those details, but nothing seems to help.
Because of the black keys, it’s kind of hard to stay out at the edge of the keyboard, where it feels lighter, and when I move my hand in for the black keys, my keyboard feels heavy to me and I think that’s adding to the challenge. I’ve tried experimenting with flatter versus more curved fingers, IOW playing with more fingertips versus less fingertips, and both ways, I just feel like it’s really a struggle to play so that all the notes sound but I’m not tensing and making my hand very tired.
IOW, I think the core problem is that if I play with my hand/wrist/arm without tension, the notes don’t sound evenly and I don’t like how it sounds. If I focus on playing to achieve the sound I like, then that’s when I get that fatigue.
Here is what it’s supposed to sound like, cued up to this spot:
Link to video(You’ll notice that my score isn’t exactly the same, and it doesn’t have those two 16th notes, but that’s ok, this is just to give you the feel for it) BTW I also notice that his hand moves in pretty close to the fallboard… I wish the camera was on his hands the whole time but it’s helpful to see even that little bit…
I don’t have a lesson again until 11/30, and my jury is on 12/12, so I’m hoping to get as much of this problem resolved as I can on my own. In fact, if I can’t resolve this problem, I will have to change and not use this as my jury piece…
Anyway, thanks in advance for any help or suggestions!
-
The repeated chords should not all be equally loud. Decide which chord you want to accent. This lets you make the repeated chords more interesting and "shape the music."
For the chords you want to accent, use the arm/shoulder/upper body. It's OK to have tension when you push a big loud chord. The trick is to relax quickly right after. Relax for the chords that you don't want to accent.
This next part is trickier and may not come together in time for your recital: use the pedal to lighten the load for your fingers. When you push the keys without the pedal, the force from the finger have to move the key-to-hammer assembly as well as the dampers. If you time and tap the pedal right, you can have the pedal lift the dampers just slightly before the fingers push the key, so more force from the fingers transfers to the hammers and less force from the fingers is "wasted" on lifting the dampers, this allows you to get more sound out of less force from the fingers.
Good luck.
-
The repeated chords should not all be equally loud. Decide which chord you want to accent. This lets you make the repeated chords more interesting and "shape the music."
For the chords you want to accent, use the arm/shoulder/upper body. It's OK to have tension when you push a big loud chord. The trick is to relax quickly right after. Relax for the chords that you don't want to accent.
This next part is trickier and may not come together in time for your recital: use the pedal to lighten the load for your fingers. When you push the keys without the pedal, the force from the finger have to move the key-to-hammer assembly as well as the dampers. If you time and tap the pedal right, you can have the pedal lift the dampers just slightly before the fingers push the key, so more force from the fingers transfers to the hammers and less force from the fingers is "wasted" on lifting the dampers, this allows you to get more sound out of less force from the fingers.
Good luck.
Ax, thank you for these comments!!
The repeated chords should not all be equally loud. Decide which chord you want to accent. This lets you make the repeated chords more interesting and "shape the music."
This part I think I have -- at least, I have it in my head. I want the downbeat to be accented and then the others not, so yes, for it to have that shape. But I feel like after the down beat, that's where the unevenness starts to appear...
For the chords you want to accent, use the arm/shoulder/upper body. It's OK to have tension when you push a big loud chord. The trick is to relax quickly right after. Relax for the chords that you don't want to accent.
I will work on this.
This next part is trickier and may not come together in time for your recital: use the pedal to lighten the load for your fingers.
So, I've been playing this passage completely without pedal. But yesterday, I played it with the pedal and indeed, it's much lighter that way. However, it also sounds muddy... I wonder if I can mitigate that with careful half pedalling... When you listen to the video, do you think he's playing with pedal? I need to listen again for that....
When you push the keys without the pedal, the force from the finger have to move the key-to-hammer assembly as well as the dampers. If you time and tap the pedal right, you can have the pedal lift the dampers just slightly before the fingers push the key, so more force from the fingers transfers to the hammers and less force from the fingers is "wasted" on lifting the dampers, this allows you to get more sound out of less force from the fingers.
I will try this, thank you!!!
You're probably right, it might be hard to get this before the jury... Although, I do have three weeks, and half-pedalling and so on is something I do a lot in other pieces. So maybe there's hope.
Because the pedal does make it so much lighter, and that might be just the tweak I need....
I shall report back!

-
It's marked staccato, not tenuto so I would not use pedal at all, especially if the composer has marked pedal indications elsewhere in the music.
Because of the black keys, it’s kind of hard to stay out at the edge of the keyboard, where it feels lighter, and when I move my hand in for the black keys, my keyboard feels heavy to me and I think that’s adding to the challenge.
Is your right hand tiring faster than your left? These chords in the right hand are directly in front of your body, even slightly to the left of it. Because of this I find it easier to let the pinky side of my right hand move further in towards the keyboard and the thumb almost at the edge of the white keys. In order words, not keeping my right hand at a straight right angle to the edge of the keyboard. Leaning a bit left might help as well, especially if it allows you to alleviate tension in the right shoulder. Perhaps see how it feels when you play the right hand an octave higher. Easier? Harder?
-
It's marked staccato, not tenuto so I would not use pedal at all, especially if the composer has marked pedal indications elsewhere in the music.
Because of the black keys, it’s kind of hard to stay out at the edge of the keyboard, where it feels lighter, and when I move my hand in for the black keys, my keyboard feels heavy to me and I think that’s adding to the challenge.
Is your right hand tiring faster than your left? These chords in the right hand are directly in front of your body, even slightly to the left of it. Because of this I find it easier to let the pinky side of my right hand move further in towards the keyboard and the thumb almost at the edge of the white keys. In order words, not keeping my right hand at a straight right angle to the edge of the keyboard. Leaning a bit left might help as well, especially if it allows you to alleviate tension in the right shoulder. Perhaps see how it feels when you play the right hand an octave higher. Easier? Harder?
Is your right hand tiring faster than your left?
Yes! LH is completely fine. It's the RH that's giving me troubles.
These chords in the right hand are directly in front of your body, even slightly to the left of it.
Yes and I think that's part of the difficulty.
Because of this I find it easier to let the pinky side of my right hand move further in towards the keyboard and the thumb almost at the edge of the white keys. In order words, not keeping my right hand at a straight right angle to the edge of the keyboard.
Ahhh! This is very helpful, thank you! I feel like I have a stiff wrist, by which I mean, when I'm moving left or right along the keyboard, my wrist does not naturally want to move (horizontally) and I do try to be more supple, but it doesn't come naturally. So that movement you're describing is probably missing here as well.
Leaning a bit left might help as well, especially if it allows you to alleviate tension in the right shoulder.
I try to lean, but maybe I can focus on doing that a little more.
Perhaps see how it feels when you play the right hand an octave higher. Easier? Harder?
As I recall, when I was first trying to get the chords into my fingers, I played it up above middle C and that was just easier. But I haven't done that in a while, I should do it just to see how it feels and look at my movements to see if there's something I'm not doing but should be when playing in the octave as written.
Re the pedal, I think it probably shouldn't have pedal, but I'm going to play around with it and see what I can hear.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login