Greetings from SFO!
-
Now to the point where the rye one doubles in size in 24 hours The wheat one gets fluffy but doesn鈥檛 change size much.
The rye one is much easier to work with than the wheat one. The wheat version sets up like concrete on whatever it touches while the rye one stays softer even if it sits on a counter or something.
Both seem to require more water than the 1:1 ratio everyone recommends. 1:1 gives a consistency something like peanut butter so I鈥檝e been adding water until the surface of the starter will level out in the jar. The only reason I do this is to make it look like the pictures on line. Your thoughts?
I see people slowly switching their rye starter over to wheat before baking with it. Is this necessary?
-
I think my starter is more like peanut butter; I follow the 1:1 ratio.
Not sure what to say about the rye starter conversion. From what @Jodi said, seems like the rye may be better for getting the starter rolling. Your observations of your two starters seem to bear that out. I only recently started experimenting with rye, but I fed a wheat starter some rye, so I'm doing kind of the reverse conversion. The bread I made with the rye-fed starter was good but I'm not sure it's worth the effort to keep multiple starters going. I think if I want to do a rye bread, I'll just use some rye in the loaf I'm making. I find the rye flour makes the bread much sticker and harder to work with, so I only do it occasionally. Lazy bum!
This first week of getting the starter going is kind of like having a newborn or a puppy in the house, isn't it? They all need constant attention! I promise it'll get easier....
-
A pumpkin-shaped sourdough loaf. How cool!
https://www.mydailysourdoughbread.com/pumpkin-shaped-sourdough/
-
So. Much. Carving!
-
Today's experiment: Honey Oat Pain de Mie
https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/recipes/honey-oat-pain-de-mie-recipe
Not a sourdough recipe. Super easy to throw together and the dough was lovely to work with.
All risen, ready to form into a loaf:
I formed the loaf and put it in the pan. You're supposed to let it rise to within an inch of the top, but I got distracted and when I went to check it I found it was all the way up to the top. I sort of gently pulled the dough from the edges of the pan and gently patted it down till I got it to the right height. Of course I could have baked it without the lid, but hey! The pullman loaf pan was the whole idea here!
End of baking:
Cooling on the rack. Still haven't tasted it. Can't wait!
We're thinking egg salad sandwiches for dinner...
-
It certainly makes a nice loaf!
-
I gradually put a good wheat flour in my starter. Now I just feed it with the wheat flour (the same one I bake with. I think once I took too much starter out - back when I had it in a much smaller jar - so I added back in rye flour to make sure it stayed zippy. Frankly you could probably mix your two starters together.
-
Threw out the wheat starter made from the dehydrated mix. It never did anything. Keeping the rye starter.
The rye one didn鈥檛 die but it hasn鈥檛 done much either. No mold, nice smell, fluffy with bubbles but never changes size. Using bottled drinking water, 1:1:1 ratio, 95F. Now I鈥檓 intrigued. People have been doing this for 1000s of years. It鈥檚 not supposed to be this hard.
Next up - proofing box. Playmate cooler, jar of hot tap water. I can refill the jar with water when it cools off. Right now it鈥檚 sitting at 76F. Temp in house is 69F so it should never go below that.
-
Thoughts on the Pullman loaf pan.
My sister spent some years as a professional baker. CIA, Etc. she always told me that cookies and such all must be made small and perfect - that only amateurs made big shaggy cookies like I did. Her breads are like your Pullman loaf, her cinnamon rolls are perfect little rounds. Very nice, very professional.
But I鈥檓 not convinced that is what I want. I鈥檓 attracted to the crusty, gnarly loaves I see on the internet. Boudin loaves were somewhere in between, but the Tartine loaf was particularly rustic.
If I ever get to the bread making stage I think I鈥檒l start there.
-
I don't think I've ever met a bread I didn't like. I love the crusty sourdough breads I've been making, but I gotta tell you that Pullman sandwich loaf was wonderful in its own way. I mean, how can you have a proper egg and cress sandwich on anything but sandwich bread?
I was on the hairy edge of getting rid of all of my bread cookbooks (Bernard Clayton, Beth Hensperger, and some others) but now I'm thinking I might hang on to them and do some experimenting. So many carbs, not enough time!
One of the Clayton books has a plan for building an outdoor bread baking oven. Mr wtg would kill me.
-
-
Starter is to the point where it will double in 24 hours.
Is it ready to bake something with or give it more time?
-
https://littlespoonfarm.com/when-is-sourdough-starter-ready/
You can perform a float test to check if your starter is ready. Drop a small spoonful of the starter into a glass of water. If it floats, it indicates that the starter is sufficiently active and ready for use.
-
Thanks!
-
Just got back from a sourdough making class. It was fun, and the teacher, who runs the class in a big camping trailer, was excellent! We each came home with a blob of dough which we will be shaping and baking tomorrow.
We also brought home some 1847 Oregon Trail starter. Pretty cool! Let me know if you want some. She showed us how to dehydrate it so it would be easy to put some in the mail.
-
Holy cow! This crazy 1847 starter, fed 1:4:4 grew so fast that it overflowed the jar in like 6 hours!
I鈥檓 throwing my starter away. Good bye Bubbles, hello John Dough!
-
And if you send them a SASE they鈥檒l send you some!
